Butternut Squash

I often credit the Thanksgiving holiday as the inspiration for my vegetarianism. The year I was 15 I realized that if I became a vegetarian I would never have to eat turkey again. Sounded good to me, so I signed on and basically never looked back. So that means I’m not one of those sad Thanksgiving vegetarians eying the smoked or deep fried or “drunken” turkey or turducken or whatever and feeling left out because the holiday centers around a big dead bird. (If those sad T-day vegetarians even exist – I am secretly of the opinion that no one actually likes turkey.)

But I can only eat so much stuffing, mashed potato, and dinner roll, so I figured it behooved me to figure out something both tasty and festive to bring to my family feast as a vegetarian main dish. I googled “vegetarian Thanksgiving” and came up with a lot of very wheat-heavy recipes, which (as phenomenal as Mushroom and Fennel Bread Pudding sounds) weren’t going to work since the point for me was to have an option besides stuffing and rolls. So I googled “vegetarian gluten-free Thanksgiving,” and, thank goodness for the interweb, came across several mentions of a Martha Stewart Living recipe for Quinoa and Butternut Squash Pie. It sounded perfect, although when I looked over the recipe I was worried that it might end up bland and lacking in depth. I was in a real rush when I finally put it together, so I didn’t have time to play with or doctor it, other than doubling the amount of parmesan.

So what, then, can I say about Quinoa and Butternut Squash Pie? I made it, we ate it. It was pretty – my squash had such wonderfully thick flesh that it didn’t really make any ring-shaped pieces for the decorative rings on top so I cut out stars instead. Other than that, my instincts were correct. It was bland, it lacked depth. It didn’t suck. People said they liked it, but I think people were too stuffed with drunken turkey to really notice or care.

Quinoa and Butternut Squash Pie

(Kind of a crappy photo because by the time we arrived I didn’t think the 20 or so guests wanted to wait to start eating until I garnished my dish and got the lighting juuuust right…)

(I also find it distracting to have to keep calling this thing a pie. It’s not a pie. It’s more of a… something like a large timbale, I guess.)

4 comments on “Butternut Squash

  1. Heather says:

    I love turkey!! But I don’t think I’ll ever be a ‘sad vegetarian’ because I just can’t imagine myself making a life choice that would make myself unhappy.

    Lynne Rosetto Kasper had a chat with Deborah Madison about veggie Thanksgiving recipes on her show just before Thanksgiving. Her suggested signature recipe was also one involving wheat, a squash lasagne, but it did sound delicious nonetheless. http://splendidtable.publicradio.org/recipes/veg_thanksgiving_index.shtml

    Your version looks much prettier than Martha’s!


  2. […] abandoned at the back of the middle shelf, all seasoned with some of the sage left over from the Quinoa Butternut Pie. I followed Deborah Madison’s instructions for roasting turnips from Vegetarian Cooking for […]

  3. scrumptious says:

    Hee hee! Prettier than Martha’s! When I was a kid my family and I had an aggressively competetive attitude at holiday-time towards Martha Stewart – we were always trying (and often suceeding) to outdo her efforts. So your comment really went to the heart of some nostalgia, Heather!

  4. kyoko says:

    butternut squash makes me think of my new favorite pumpkin family member: kabocha! it’s got SO much wonderful flavor i wonder if it would help with the blandness of this dish?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s